Is Solutions Journalism a Solution?

by | Sep 28, 2026

Publisher's Column: Focusing on solutions is growing in Hawaiʻi.

Hawaiʻi has a media problem. A public policy report published last year by the Hawaii Institute of Public Affairs showed that the number of local newspapers across the islands was cut in half—dropping from 27 to less than 15—over the last two decades. Fortunately, the tide is starting to turn. Since last year, more than five new journalism entities have emerged in Hawaiʻi. Of these new organizations, three (including ours) are indigenous-led, and two of us provide solutions journalism.

What is Solutions Journalism?

“In a way, you’ll know it’s a solutions journalism story because it will have a different psychological effect on you. With traditional journalism, which is problem-focused, the effect tends to make us want to go to bed and pull the covers over our heads,” says Solutions Journalism Network co-founder Tina Rosenberg.

If you’re reading a solutions story, it makes you feel empowered, excited, and aware that there is real momentum out there to change things.

Tina Rosenberg

While journalists have written solutions-oriented stories for decades, the formal term first gained traction in 1998. Scholar Susan Benesch published an article in the Columbia Journalism Review documenting this evolving approach. Far from mere “good news,” she explained solutions journalism as rigorous reporting on “what’s right, hoping that someone can imitate it.” A few years later, in 2003, the French organization Reporters d’Espoirs (Reporters of Hope) launched with a network of professionals dedicated entirely to solution-based reporting.

Today, we practice solutions journalism under the framework defined by the Solutions Journalism Network (SJN), an independent nonprofit founded in 2013. The organization provides robust training and models for newsrooms globally. Co-founders David Bornstein, Tina Rosenberg, and Courtney Martin launched the initiative after Bornstein and Rosenberg spent years evaluating responses to social systemic issues in their New York Times column, Fixes.

Articles embracing this framework must incorporate four distinct pillars:

  • Response: A detailed look at a credible response to a problem.
  • Insight: Actionable insights and transferable lessons learned.
  • Evidence: Empirical data showing whether the response is working.
  • Limitations: A transparent look at the shortcomings or gaps in the response.

The definition of solutions journalism is expansive when the history of a place is brought into consideration. Hawaiʻi has a long history of moʻolelo (storytelling), with stories passed down through generations about all parts of life. These stories are not restricted to struggle and did not have a label as we have constructed with modern day journalism terminology. Often times, these stories include responses to problems we are experiencing today. While Hawaiʻi undoubtedly needs more media outlets, can it specifically benefit from a deeper commitment to solutions journalism? We choose to answer this question by applying the framework itself.

The Response: More [Solutions] Journalism

Solutions journalism is expanding right alongside the broader local media landscape. Hawaiʻi Community Journal (HCJ; formerly Overstory) is the first publication in the islands entirely dedicated to solutions journalism and the first local outlet listed in the international solutions journalism directory. However, we were not the first in Hawaiʻi to practice it. Honolulu Civil Beat produced Hawaiʻi’s first certified solutions journalism trainer less than a decade ago, embedding the practice directly into their newsroom operations. Our co-founder later became the second certified trainer in the state. More recently, Hawaiʻi Radio Hour participated in a year-long cohort focused on indigenous climate solutions, which has since expanded into Kilo Hawaiʻi—an independent, indigenous-led newsroom.

This year, HCJ has collaborated with other entities, like Hawaiʻi Radio Hour, who are practicing solutions journalism as well as professionals open to  applying the framework.  Each collaboration utilizes a custom editorial lens that grounds writing in both a solutions framework and values-based, ethical storytelling. HCJ was also awarded a grant and invitation to the Solutions Visuals – Climate Beacon Newsroom Initiative to expand visual coverage of climate solutions. 

Insights: Systemic Shifts

Expanding solutions journalism across Hawaiʻi creates a tangible opportunity to rebuild community trust in the media, preserve local storytelling, and address deep-seated regional challenges.

This model adds a vital framework that complements traditional news and investigative reporting, recognizing that a healthy community requires a diverse media ecosystem. Traditional journalism plays a crucial role in exposing corruption and documenting crises, but it fulfills only part of the civic equation. By introducing and expanding a solutions-oriented approach alongside existing standards, we provide the structural blueprints to build on what is working and pursue new possibilities.

Consider the cost of living and affordable housing, which remain priority concerns for local families. While the State of Hawaiʻi Consolidated Plan for 1995 projected a demand for roughly 17,000 low-to-moderate-income housing units, the 2024 Hawaiʻi Housing Planning Study released by the state reveals a staggering shortage of 64,490 units. Ongoing and pervasive issues of this scale require going beyond the increase in need, to examine the systems and root causes while also providing helpful information to the reader.

HCJ has published solutions coverage on local housing shortages. In 2027, we will partner with the inaugural SPEED Summit to explore solutions to permitting complications and construction delays. This gathering stems directly from the newly formed SPEED Task Force (Simplifying Permitting for Enhanced Economic Development), mandated by the state to clear the bureaucratic bottlenecks causing slow housing growth and soaring prices.

We can look to peer publications for similar shifts. In 2025, The Salt Lake Tribune published a series on affordable housing using a solutions framework. Following the coverage, the Utah Housing Corporation proactively reached out to the newsroom to collaborate on public outreach programs for first-time homebuyers. As solutions grow and evolve, journalism has an opportunity to grow with it.

Evidence: Shifting Mindsets

New solutions take time to gather evidence. Solutions journalism in Hawaiʻi is still in its nascent stages, but proof that the practice is growing across the media ecosystem is something to pay attention to.

Global research compiled by the Solutions Journalism Network demonstrates the clear, quantifiable impact of this methodology when it has been deployed in other newsrooms. Studies show that audiences who interact with solutions-focused reporting experience a notable shift in how they process complex issues. It increases emotional connection to the subject matter, strengthens an individual’s sense of personal agency to contribute to positive change, and heightens their desire to learn more.

A research study conducted by SmithGeiger in 2021 showed that trust jumps to 83% when audiences encounter a solutions-focused story, compared to just 55% for a problem-only report. The audience loyalty also increases. Readers of solutions journalism revisit articles, with nine times more sessions, spending an average of 52 seconds longer per sessions.

Further data indicates that readers feel a stronger connection to the organizations mentioned and are significantly more likely to share what they have learned within their personal networks. You can explore more evidence in the Solutions Journalism Network Impact Story directory.

Limitations: Nascent Stages & Attention Economies

Without wealthy benefactors, media entities in Hawaiʻi remain highly dependent on advertising revenue or for nonprofit newsrooms, philanthropic donations. A state-of-the-sector report published this year by the Hawaii Alliance of Nonprofit Organizations (HANO) revealed that only 27% of local nonprofits are currently able to pay all full-time staff a living wage. Additionally, 69% reported major challenges securing funds to cover full operational costs, a strain compounded by recent federal funding cuts. New nonprofit newsrooms face tight operational constraints in a crowded landscape for charitable dollars.

Patience is required. Responses to problems take time to mature and often, there is an ebb and flow of course corrections, making the journey to a solution nuanced and long. Hawaiʻi is also  unique in that it possesses a rich indigenous knowledge base capable of informing modern systems change, but sharing these lessons requires an ethics of care that rejects transactional, fast-paced media models.

This level of depth frequently clashes with profitable modern click-bait practices and must compete for an audience whose average digital attention span maxes out at a mere 90 seconds.On a broader scale, legacy news stations continue to navigate shifting government access, while social media algorithms, digital influencers, and generative AI tools rapidly dominate the information landscape. Complex, multi-layered solutions reporting must work twice as hard to cut through this digital noise.

To do this, we need more journalists who understand, practice, and are certified in solutions journalism. There is currently no dedicated course at the University of Hawaiʻi for solutions journalism. Meanwhile, journalism programs across the U.S. are seeing a steady decrease in enrollment. There will need to be more collaborative efforts to educate on journalism in Hawaiʻi if we are to see growth.

More, Not Less

Despite these very real limitations, solutions journalism brings invaluable perspective and critical volume to local reporting.In 1843, King Kamehameha III (Kauikeaouli) penned the motto that guides Hawaiʻi: “Ua Mau ke Ea o ka ʻĀina i ka Pono”—the life of the land is perpetuated in righteousness. That very same year, the historic nūpepa (newspaper) Ka Nonanona stepped up to publish critical community information when a British naval captain attempted to unilaterally seize control of the kingdom. When the sovereign government was formally restored, Ka Nonanona had played a critical role. Hawaiʻi’s stories have always belonged to its people, and our history is one of perseverance. By working collectively and turning our editorial focus toward how our communities respond to systemic issues, solutions journalism could become a part of the solution.

Author

Share this article

We are a member of the Solutions Journalism Network directory and are committed to creating and sharing rigorous reporting on responses to social and environmental problems.

Together, We Can Make an Impact

Every donation widens our reach and deepens our reporting. Help us tell more of the stories Hawaiʻi needs to hear.